> Who knows the answer? Consider 3 circles: A, B and C. Where A and B overlap, it creates area W. Where B and?

Who knows the answer? Consider 3 circles: A, B and C. Where A and B overlap, it creates area W. Where B and?

Posted at: 2015-01-07 
If A,B and C all overlap, i.e. each the other two, then logically A&B, B&C and A&C must inevitably overlap; i.e the necessary and sufficient conditions for the existence of W, X and Y are given.

However some of the areas might simply be different names for the same area and therefore not enjoy a separate existence. Consider for example 3 concentric circles A, B and C of increasing radius. Then areas W, Y and Z are all the same area. Nonetheless they all exist!

All three must exist. If A, B, and C overlap then A and B overlap etc.





Z is a subset of W.



Z is a subset of X.



Z is a subset of Y.

Well... are W,X, & Y necessarily at least partially exclusive?



Are the three circles of the same diameter?



(As you state it, the three circles might be concentric y'know.)



If they are exclusive, then - If Z exists then, since A.B.& C share



at least some small common area and thus W X &Y must exist.

Z can only exist if W, X and Y exists. Therefore if you say Z exists then W, X, and Y should also exists.!

Consider the trivial solution:



Z = (A + B + C), and A,B, and C are non-zero.



If Z exists, (A + B), (B + C), and (A + C) exist.



Proof format escapes me.

Who knows the answer?



Consider 3 circles: A, B and C.





Where A and B overlap, it creates area W.





Where B and C overlap, it creates area X.





Where A and C overlap, it creates area Y.





Where A, B and C overlap, it creates area Z.





If area Z exists, must area W, X or Y exist? If so, which ones?